Debate lacked answers

Published in the Jamaica Gleaner: Friday | August 10, 2007

Winston Lawson, Contributor

I was not surprised that Dr. Phillips got the edge on presentation over Dr. Baugh, by virtue of his own style. Dr. Baugh did fine, however, he is not a strong match to debate Dr. Phillips. His personality, in itself, is less emotive and he is less articulate.

I am unable to concur with Dr. Phillips that the root cause of crime is the narcotics trade. He certainly gave me the impression that this was his view. Dr. Baugh is correct in attributing it to joblessness, along with issues of family and values and attitudes. It was disappointing that not much was said as it relates to solutions for these issues, notwithstanding that recommendations are outlined in the JLP Manifesto. I, for one, believe that we should start looking at areas where we can legislate solutions in these areas, despite the potential dangers. I suppose to mitigate the dangers we could seek consensus from the people. For instance, would Jamaicans support legislation which speaks to children being in their homes by say 8:00 p.m., certainly on weekdays?

Dr. Phillips did not do too much to convince us of the steps to fight corruption particularly when one of the panellists mentioned Trafigura and Solutrea. There are numerous recommendations in the JLP Manifesto which addresses the issue of corruption. As to whether they will actually implement them, or have the opportunity to implement them, only time will tell.

Source of funds

Dr. Baugh should have also been clearer and more specific on how they propose to finance the very well-intentioned programmes in their manifesto. While I am one who believes that any government can and will find funds to carry out programmes that they absolutely believe in, it is still very reasonable of citizens to request the proposed source of funds from any political party.

Both debaters seemed to be supportive of performance pay for our teachers. It may be one of several ways to raise the quality of the service. My boss has always insisted, "What gets measured, gets done". I agree. I would, however, be interested to hear both their views on performance-related pay for politicians! As leaders, they should lead by example.

Winston Lawson is president, Manchester Chamber of Commerce.