Election 2002 Home » News
»
Blair wants campaign finance laws
Garwin
Davis, Assistant News Editor
Bishop
Herro Blair, the Political Ombudsman, says the practice of
buying votes was threatening the country's democracy and that
he would be strongly advocating for the enactment of a campaign
finance law after the general election.
In
an interview with The Sunday Gleaner on Friday, Bishop Blair
said it was disturbing to see the huge sums of money being
spent to buy votes, a pattern he said that was widespread
in constituencies across the island.
"I
don't think we have ever had a situation in our history where
so much money is being spent in a political campaign,"
he said. "It is sad, however, that a lot of this money
is being used to buy votes. This certainly cannot be good
for our democracy. I will, in my report to Parliament after
the elections, be making a strong argument for campaign financing
which to me is the sensible way forward."
He
points to other countries like the United States where strong
laws governing campaign finance prevent the sort of abuses
that happen locally.
In
the United States, the Federal Election Commission (FECA)
requires candidate committees, party committees and Public
Action Committees (PAC) to file periodic reports disclosing
the money they raise and spend. Candidates must identify,
for example, all PACs and party committees that give them
contributions, and they must identify individuals who give
them more than $200 in a year.
Additionally,
they must disclose expenditures exceeding $200 per year to
any individual or vendor. The FECA also places limits on contributions
by individuals and groups to candidates, party committees
and PACs.
Bishop
Blair did not say whether the buying of votes was being done
across party lines or whether certain constituencies were
specifically targeted.
Sources,
however, told The Sunday Gleaner that "a lot of money"
was being pumped "on the ground" by both the ruling
People's National Party (PNP) and the Opposition Jamaica Labour
Party (JLP) in constituencies, which are considered marginal,
with the hope of tipping the balance in their favour.
"It
would be easy to blame the PNP because that's the party in
power and in possession of state funds," one senior political
source notes. "However this is not the case as the JLP
is also actively involved in the buying of votes. Certain
seats are being targeted and believe me when I say big money
has been dropping -- voters in some of these areas are having
a field day -- today they are PNP tomorrow they are JLP."
The
Sunday Gleaner, on Friday, was taken on a tour of two such
constituencies within the Corporate Area. Sources within both
areas say that a large number of rental cars have been brought
in for the sole purpose of "making the youths dem feel
good" and for getting the votes on election day.
"It's
a feel good factor," one source notes. "Give the
key people in the areas access to cars and they will work
for you all the way through the election. Give them some money
to go with that and they will actively recruit the votes too.
The danger here is that these people don't really have any
loyalty and nobody knows what they will do when they go behind
that voting booth. For the time being though, the spending
frenzy continues."
Asked
where the money was coming from to fund such missions, the
source notes that "both parties have their fair share
of wealthy supporters. Money is not a problem for both parties,"
he said.
"The
PNP may have an edge in support but the gap is not as huge
as some people would want to believe. Just look at the expensive
ad campaign going on. In some cases the JLP is out-spending
the PNP. The only way out of this is for the country to have
strict campaign finance laws where the source of contributions
can be known. That's the only way we will ever have a level
playing field and where the smaller parties can have a say."
The
need for a political campaign finance law has been a topic
for much debate locally.Þ The debate has, however, been
heightened recently with reports that both the JLP and the
PNP were being flooded with money from deep pocket contributors.
Officials
of both parties have regularly insisted that they would have
no problem supporting campaign financing, saying that it would
be in the interest of the country.
They
have also denied deliberately accepting money from "unscrupulous
sources" to fund campaigns, saying that contributions,
before accepted, "are carefully screened".
"We
would want to know the source of a large donation," PNP
General Secretary Maxine Henry-Wilson said. "If it's
not something we are comfortable with we would not accept
it." Her counterpart in the JLP, Dr. Ken Baugh, said
his party has always been transparent in its fundraising affairs
and at all times seek in operate in a very professional and
forthright way."
For
Bishop Blair though, the proof remains in the pudding. "Action
speaks louder than words," he said.
|