Home
» Articles »
The fundamental issue for October 16
Martin
Henry
AT
THE top of the list of rights and freedoms guaranteed by the
Charter of Rights and Freedoms in a "free, peaceful,
orderly and democratic society" is "the right of
everyone to life, liberty, and security of the person and
the right not to be deprived thereof except in accordance
with the principles of fundamental justice and in execution
of the sentence of a court in respect of a criminal offence
of which he has been convicted."
In
the midst of the torrential rains from Tropical Storm Lili
on Sunday morning, there was sustained shooting in the Upper
Oxford Street area of downtown Kingston. A woman was shot
and injured. She is one of thousands of people who have been
shot and injured, and thousands of others who have been murdered
as Jamaica bled its way close to the top spot in the world
for murder rate after 40 years of Independence.
The
shooting and injury were no surprise. They happen every day,
with an average of 2.8 murders per day. A man was recently
interviewed on media and asked about his feelings at the murder
of his sister and her husband. "Mi no feel no way; mi
get used to it now," was his response!
What
will be a shocking surprise is if anyone is arrested and brought
to trial for the Sunday morning shooting and injury, or for
any of the recent gruesome barrel murders in that general
downtown area. Many killings are from vendettas, reprisals
and community 'justice' as citizens settle their grievances
themselves without reference to the state. Witnesses are routinely
murdered using terrorism to frustrate the trial of the very
few who are arrested for serious crimes.
No
one feels secure in person or feels that life and liberty
enjoy adequate protection from the murderous hands of fellow
citizens by the powers of the state. Furthermore the state
itself infringes the right to life, liberty and the security
of the person by the actions of its security arm particularly
against certain segments of the population. There is a freedom
against discrimination.
Soon
after October 16 Parliamentarians will be swearing the new
Oath of Allegiance: "I do swear that I will be faithful
and bear true allegiance to Jamaica, that I will uphold and
defend the Constitution and the laws of Jamaica and that I
will conscientiously and impartially discharge my responsibilities
to the people of Jamaica."
Some
will unblushingly take the oath as representatives of communities
which have suspended freedom of expression, freedom of movement,
freedom of belief of political doctrines, due process of law
by the state authority, and even the right to life and liberty.
The president of the PNP, and Prime Minister, has declared
on the campaign trail that his hands are not daubed with blood.
Mr. Patterson, a Q.C. lawyer, is clearly implying that there
are hands daubed with blood. Whose hands among the 60? Surely
the Head of Government must do more than declare his innocence
and vigorously preside over a Government determined to use
the executive power of the Consti-tution to protect and uphold
all the rights and freedoms of all the people of Jamaica all
the time.
The
Charter speaks of the "principles of fundamental justice."
Surely these principles include innocent until proven guilty
by due process, equality before the law including law enforcement
by the security forces, the right to a speedy trial and to
bail, the right not to incriminate oneself under duress.
But
no less, these fundamental principles of justice include the
rights of aggrieved parties to settlement and redress through
the proper and lawful punishment of offenders. We ignore this
side of justice to our great peril. Much of the spiralling
lawlessness engulfing our land and corrupting constitutional
rights and freedoms stems from the failure of aggrieved parties
to obtain justice as redress through the state authority.
In
defence of rights and freedoms, the state must catch and punish
murderers, rapists, extortionists, dons, praedial larcenists,
invaders of property rights, politicians who issue guns (and
there have been allegations for this campaign), extra-judicial
state executioners and beaters, and all other species of criminals
abusing the rights of others. The fundamental principles of
justice demand this.
The
Political Ombudsman has discovered to his great surprise
that there are communities where the MP for five years
has never set foot because of fear and security concerns.
The Prime Minister, the Head of the Jamaican Government, would
have to travel with the whole army to enter certain pockets
of this country which he leads and which has no rebel movements
or war. The Leader of the Opposition, in his own West Kingston
constituency, cannot at liberty enter the PNP stronghold area
of Matthews Lane.
We
who have no security detail, have long been circumscribed
to certain safe passages and places. So well established is
this curtailment of our constitutional freedom of movement
that it is no longer a cause of shock and alarm. The Charter
of Rights and Freedoms guarantees the "right to freedom
of movement the right of every person lawfully in Jamaica,
to move around freely throughout Jamaica, to reside in any
part of Jamaica."
Orlando
Patterson, in his Jamaica 40 Independence Lecture, reminisced
of his freedom to roam Trench Town at nights, following the
revivalist meetings as a young university student, an experience
out of which came his famous first novel The Children of Sisyphus
at the time of Independence.
SYSTEMATIC
TORCHING
My
wife recounts the political violence and threats, the systematic
torching, looting and enforced exodus in that very area of
Kingston a decade and a half later. The internal refugees
fleeing with only what they could carry on their heads and
in handcarts, abandoning their houses, under the gun, to go
up in flames as our political version of ethnic cleansing
proceeded citizens, who no longer had a right to reside
in any part of Jamaica, or to move around freely, or to enjoy
their property, or to express their views, or to associate
with whom they wish.
All
of us are circumscribed to our various corners by political
boundaries, by crime and violence, and most of all by a generalised
fear for security of person. We are confined by our burglar
bars. We are confined to safe hours and a dwindling number
of safe routes. (The main arterial route to the Norman Manley
International Airport is now under the gun). We are obstructed
by roadblocks mounted by protesting fellow citizens and by
campaigning political parties. Entire, long established roads
connecting communities have been allowed to fall into such
disrepair as to be impassable.
And
all this while the Parliament seeks to promulgate a new Charter
to provide "more comprehensive and effective protection
for the fundamental rights and freedoms of all persons in
Jamaica". This is the fundamental issue of October 16
and beyond for citizens and Government.
About
this writer
Martin
Henry is a communications consultant.
|